Casper Original Pillow review

Casper's Original Pillow is the soft, easy-care choice. It uses a pillow-in-pillow design: a supportive inner pillow sits inside a softer outer pillow, both filled with recycled down-alternative fibers, under a 100% cotton percale cover. Casper says its medium profile suits side sleepers and that stomach sleepers can take the inner pillow out for a low loft. The whole pillow is machine washable, which none of the foam and latex picks above it fully allow. The standard was $67.50 when we checked, against $75 regular. For side sleepers who wake with real neck or shoulder pain, the limits are clear: fiber fill gives less firm support under a heavy head than foam or latex, you can only make it lower rather than higher, and there is no shoulder cutout. Casper accepts returns within 30 days if the item meets its conditions and backs the pillow with a 1-year limited warranty.

Who it is for

Side sleepers with mild neck discomfort who want a soft, fully washable pillow.

Price

Standard $67.50 on the Casper US store when checked (regular $75).

Sale price $67.50 SAVE 10% Comp. Value: Regular price $75
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 8, 2026.

Key features

• Pillow-in-pillow design with a supportive inner pillow and soft outer pillow
• Recycled down-alternative fiber fill
• 100% cotton percale cover
• Fully machine washable
• Inner pillow can be removed for a lower loft

Strengths and weaknesses

• Strength: Whole pillow goes in the washing machine
• Strength: Medium profile Casper recommends for side sleepers
• Strength: Low price at $67.50 for a standard
• Weakness: Fiber fill gives less firm support than foam or latex
• Weakness: Height adjustment only goes lower, by removing the insert
• Weakness: 30-day returns and a 1-year limited warranty

Key facts

• Standard price: $67.50 when checked
• Fill: Recycled down alternative
• Returns: 30 days
• Warranty: 1-year limited

Where it ranks

Casper Original Pillow is No. 6 in our Best Pillows for Side Sleepers verdict.