8 Best Wine Clubs of 2026
By the HearSmart research desk · Updated November 12, 2026 · Next review December 27, 2026 · 8 products compared
The short version
Firstleaf is the easiest club to start with, because a taste quiz picks the wines and the Classic plan works out at $16.50 per bottle after a $44.95 first box. Wine Access is the strongest curated club and the best gift, with 6 bottles every quarter for $150 and shipping included. Splash Wines is the budget pick at 6 bottles for $59 or 15 for $89 with free shipping, and Winc suits drinkers who want to choose every bottle at 20% off with free shipping. SommSelect is for collectors who want sommelier picks and a blind-tasting club, The California Wine Club and Gold Medal Wine Club focus on small California wineries from $49 a shipment, and Vinebox is the tasting-sample box for people who want to try six wines a month without opening full bottles.
Short answer
Firstleaf is the best wine club for most wine drinkers in 2026: a taste quiz picks the wines, and the Classic plan costs $44.95 for the first box, then $16.50 per bottle. Wine Access suits gift buyers and curious drinkers, with 6 bottles every quarter for $150 per shipment, and Splash Wines is the cheapest at 6 bottles for $59 with free shipping, as of November 2026. Collectors who want sommelier picks should look at SommSelect, which starts at $99 for 3 bottles.
This list is for US wine drinkers and gift buyers who want to compare wine clubs on price per bottle and on how the wines are chosen. We compared documented features and published US prices for 8 clubs sold today: personalized clubs that learn your taste, sommelier-curated clubs, low-cost case subscriptions, California winery clubs and a tasting-sample box. Scores weigh performance at 40%, ease of use at 25% and value at 35%, where performance covers curation, plan choice, wine quality tiers and guarantees, and value is mainly the price per bottle. Facts and prices come from each company's own website as shown on November 12, 2026. Naked Wines, Laithwaites, WSJ Wine and Wine.com blocked every check from our location, so we could not confirm their terms and left them out. Bright Cellars now sends visitors to Winc's website, so Winc covers it here. Wine can only ship to adults 21 and over in states that allow it, and most clubs add shipping or tax at checkout, so compare the full shipment total.
Figures worth knowing
- 17.1%E-commerce made up 17.1% of total U.S. retail sales in the second quarter of 2026, seasonally adjusted, according to the Census Bureau.Source: U.S. Census Bureau
- 28.8%Online sales accounted for 28.8% of retail sales in Great Britain in September 2026, down from 28.9% in August, according to ONS.Source: Office for National Statistics
- 78%78% of EU internet users aged 16 to 74 bought or ordered goods or services online in 2025, while 95% used the internet.Source: Eurostat
- 56.4%Mobile devices were used for 56.4% of U.S. online holiday transactions in November and December 2025, according to Adobe Analytics.Source: Adobe
- 37%37% of UK parcel recipients faced a problem with their most recent delivery in 2025, according to Citizens Advice.Source: Citizens Advice
- 19.3%An estimated 19.3% of U.S. online sales will be returned in 2025, according to NRF and Happy Returns.Source: National Retail Federation
The ranking at a glance
- 1FirstleafEveryday wine drinkers who want picks matched to their taste8.8
- 2Wine AccessGift buyers and curious drinkers who want expert picks8.6
- 3Splash WinesBudget buyers who want the lowest price per bottle8.5
- 4WincDrinkers who want to choose every bottle themselves8.3
- 5SommSelectSerious drinkers and collectors who want sommelier picks8.1
- 6The California Wine ClubFans of small California wineries8.1
- 7Gold Medal Wine ClubGift buyers who want a simple tiered club7.8
- 8VineboxPeople who want to taste six wines a month without full bottles7.2
How we make the call
Every entry gets a 0 to 10 rating on the three criteria below, and the order follows the weighted total. The ratings rest on the documented features and published prices on each maker's own pages, never hands-on testing.
- 40%Performance
- 25%Ease of use
- 35%Value
No. 1, top ranked
FirstleafA personalized wine club that picks bottles from a taste quiz and your ratings.
8.8of 10Best for Everyday wine drinkers who want picks matched to their taste
- Performance
- 8.6
- Ease of use
- 9.0
- Value
- 8.8
Price
Classic plan: $44.95 first box, then $16.50 per bottle; shipping extra on regular club orders
Quoted from the Firstleaf pricing page on November 12, 2026:
Classic Quality everyday wines, boxed at our lowest pricing! $44.95 first box then $16.50/bottle
Firstleaf is built for people who do not want to read wine labels. You answer a short taste quiz, Firstleaf picks the wines, and your ratings shape later boxes. There are four plans: Classic costs $44.95 for the first box and then $16.50 per bottle, Preferred is $59.95 then $19, Premier is $74.95 then $21.50 with one fine wine in every box, and Fine Wine is $104.95 then $26.50. On the 6-bottle Classic plan a regular club order costs $99 plus shipping, and a 14-bottle option gives 14 bottles for the price of 12. Firstleaf delivers every 2 to 12 weeks, lets you change the date and plan, and charges no subscription fee. Members get 30% off in its wine store, and every plan carries a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Firstleaf says its wines have won 4,036 awards. The catch is shipping: only the intro box ships free, so add shipping to the $99 club price when you compare.
What it does well
- +Lowest per-bottle price among the personalized clubs here at $16.50
- +No subscription fees, and you can change plan size and frequency
- +100% satisfaction guarantee on every plan
Where it falls short
- −Regular club orders add shipping; only the intro box ships free
- −Wines are Firstleaf's own selections, not well-known estates
- −Higher tiers cost up to $26.50 per bottle
- Price per bottle
- $16.50 to $26.50 after the first box
- First box
- From $44.95 with free shipping
- Box size
- 6 bottles, or 14 for the price of 12
- Frequency
- Every 2 to 12 weeks
- Guarantee
- 100% satisfaction guarantee
No. 2
Wine AccessExpert-curated wine clubs, from a quarterly Discovery Club to Champagne and collector clubs.
8.6of 10Best for Gift buyers and curious drinkers who want expert picks
- Performance
- 9.2
- Ease of use
- 8.6
- Value
- 8.0
Price
Discovery Club: $150 per quarterly shipment of 6 bottles ($25 per bottle), shipping included
Quoted from the Wine Access pricing page on November 12, 2026:
Exclusive access to 6 rare, distinctive bottles, delivered quarterly – $150 per shipment
Wine Access runs a family of clubs, and the Discovery Club is the one most people should start with. It sends 6 bottles 4 times a year for $150 per shipment, which is $25 a bottle, in Mixed, All Reds or All Whites options. Wine Access says it aims for classic and off-the-beaten-path bottles and that about 1 out of 18 wines it tastes make the cut. Members get new wines in every box, complimentary shipping, tasting and pairing cards, video tastings and 10% off other Wine Access purchases, and Wine Access issues a credit for any bottle that fails to impress. Pausing and cancelling are allowed at any time. Higher tiers raise the price per bottle: the Connoisseurs Club sends 2 bottles for $150 a quarter, the Champagne Club 4 bottles for $200 to $250, and the Collector's Club 1 bottle for $250 to $400. The Discovery Club is also sold as a gift, which makes Wine Access an easy present for someone who likes to learn about wine.
What it does well
- +Complimentary shipping on every club box
- +Credit for any bottle that fails to impress
- +10% off all other Wine Access purchases for members
Where it falls short
- −Discovery Club works out at $25 per bottle, more than the budget clubs
- −Only 4 shipments a year on most clubs
- −No taste quiz; the team chooses every wine
- Price per bottle
- $25 in the Discovery Club
- Shipment
- 6 bottles, 4 times a year
- Clubs
- Discovery, Connoisseurs, Champagne, Collector's and more
- Shipping
- Complimentary for members
- Guarantee
- Credit for any bottle that fails to impress
No. 3
Splash WinesA low-cost wine subscription that ships 6 or 15-bottle cases with free shipping.
8.5of 10Best for Budget buyers who want the lowest price per bottle
- Performance
- 7.4
- Ease of use
- 8.8
- Value
- 9.6
Price
6 bottles for $59 or 15 bottles for $89, free shipping; monthly, every other month or quarterly
Quoted from the Splash Wines pricing page on November 12, 2026:
6 bottles for $59 & free shipping
Splash Wines is the cheapest way on this list to keep wine in the house. Its subscription sends 6 bottles for $59 or 15 bottles for $89, both with free shipping, which works out at about $9.83 and $5.93 a bottle. You choose red, white or mixed, set delivery to monthly, every other month or quarterly, and can upgrade from the Standard tier to better wines for a higher price. New subscribers get $20 off the first shipment with the code SUBSCRIBE, which Splash says makes 15 bottles $69. Splash also sells curated cases and a build-your-own 15-bottle case with no membership, and its Gotta-Love-It Guarantee covers bottles that do not meet your expectations. What you give up is personalization: there is no taste quiz, so you pick a color and a tier, and Splash picks the bottles. For party hosts and everyday drinkers who care most about price, that trade is worth it.
What it does well
- +About $5.93 per bottle on the 15-bottle case, the lowest on this list
- +$20 off the first shipment with the code SUBSCRIBE
- +Gotta-Love-It Guarantee on bottles you do not enjoy
Where it falls short
- −No taste quiz or ratings-based personalization
- −Standard tier wines are everyday bottles, not collector wines
- −Wine type is limited to red, white or mixed
- Price per bottle
- About $9.83 (6 bottles) or $5.93 (15 bottles)
- Case sizes
- 6 or 15 bottles
- Frequency
- Monthly, every other month or quarterly
- Shipping
- Free
- Guarantee
- Gotta-Love-It Guarantee
No. 4
WincA membership wine club where you pick your own bottles at 20% off with free shipping.
8.3of 10Best for Drinkers who want to choose every bottle themselves
- Performance
- 8.0
- Ease of use
- 8.8
- Value
- 8.4
Price
Member prices from $16.80 per bottle (regular $21); 6-bottle membership ships every month with free shipping
Quoted from the Winc pricing page on November 12, 2026:
NV Déclassé Red Wine Blend California $16.80 Regular price $21
Winc works more like a members' wine shop than a mystery box. You pick a 6-Bottle Membership, which ships 6 wines every month, or a 12-Bottle Membership, then fill the box yourself. Members get 20% off every order, always free shipping, first access to new wines and an additional 10% off for 12 or more bottles, and you can skip any month. If you do not want to choose, Winc's Palate Profile Quiz asks 6 questions and suggests wines you can keep or swap. Member prices start at $16.80 a bottle for its NV Déclassé Red Wine Blend, which is $21 at the regular price, and most member favorites we saw were $16.80 to $23.20. Winc also sells 6-bottle packs without a membership, though you lose the member price. Bright Cellars' website now points to a Winc page, so former Bright Cellars customers will land here. Winc suits people who like to choose; if you want the lowest price per bottle, Splash Wines is cheaper.
What it does well
- +You choose every bottle, or swap the recommended ones
- +Free shipping on every member order
- +Packs can be bought without a membership
Where it falls short
- −Member prices of around $17 to $23 a bottle cost more than Splash Wines
- −The 6-bottle plan ships every month unless you skip
- −Wines are mostly Winc's own labels
- Price per bottle
- From $16.80 member price
- Member discount
- 20% off, plus 10% off for 12+ bottles
- Plans
- 6-Bottle and 12-Bottle Memberships
- Shipping
- Always free for members
- Taste quiz
- 6 questions
No. 5
SommSelectSommelier-curated wine clubs, from 3-bottle clubs to a blind-tasting club.
8.1of 10Best for Serious drinkers and collectors who want sommelier picks
- Performance
- 9.0
- Ease of use
- 7.8
- Value
- 7.2
Price
From $99 for 3 bottles (The 3 Essential Whites) plus 1% insurance and shipping
Quoted from the SommSelect pricing page on November 12, 2026:
Three Bottles $99 +1% Insurance & Shipping
SommSelect is the club for people who already know they like wine and want a sommelier to push them further. Its clubs run from The 3 Essential Whites at $99 and The 3 Essential Reds at $109 for 3 bottles, through The Explore 4 at $118 for four bottles, to The Somm 6 at $209 and The Somm 6 Reds at $235 for six. The Blind 6, at $225, sends six concealed bottles so you can train yourself to taste blind, and The Sparkling Voyager sends four sparkling bottles quarterly for $199. Shipments can be monthly, bi-monthly or quarterly depending on the club, and SommSelect notifies members before billing. Every club price adds 1% insurance and shipping, and free shipping only starts on orders over $375. Prepaid 3, 6 and 12-month clubs are sold for gifts. At about $29.50 to $39 a bottle it costs more than the other curated clubs here, so it suits enthusiasts more than casual drinkers.
What it does well
- +The widest range of club themes on this list, including a blind-tasting club
- +Red-only, white-only and sparkling clubs
- +Prepaid memberships make simple gifts
Where it falls short
- −About $29.50 to $39 per bottle, the highest of the curated clubs here
- −Adds 1% insurance and shipping to every club price
- −Free shipping only on orders over $375
- Price per bottle
- About $29.50 (Explore 4) to $39 (Somm 6 Reds)
- Starting price
- $99 for 3 bottles
- Frequency
- Monthly, bi-monthly or quarterly
- Shipping
- 1% insurance and shipping added
- Gift options
- Prepaid 3, 6 and 12-month clubs
No. 6
The California Wine ClubA monthly club that features small, family-run California wineries since 1990.
8.1of 10Best for Fans of small California wineries
- Performance
- 8.2
- Ease of use
- 8.2
- Value
- 7.8
Price
Premier Series from $49 per shipment; Signature Series from $134; Aged Cabernet Series from $269
Quoted from the The California Wine Club pricing page on November 12, 2026:
From $49.00 Premier Series
The California Wine Club has worked with small, family-run wineries since 1990, and each month it features different artisan wineries and hand-selects wines for members, with tasting notes and pairing suggestions. There are three clubs: the Premier Series starts at $49, the Signature Series at $134 for limited-production wines, and the Aged Cabernet Series at $269. Members get 20% off when they reorder favorites, add bottles to a shipment or send a gift, and shipping is free on any mix of 12 reordered bottles. The Love It Guarantee replaces a bottle you did not love, members can cancel at any time with no hidden fees, and a referred friend who joins earns you a $50 credit. The club's homepage shows starting prices but not the number of bottles in each starting shipment, so check the plan page before you compare price per bottle. It is a good fit for drinkers who like the story behind small California wineries.
What it does well
- +Cancel at any time with no hidden fees
- +Love It Guarantee replaces a bottle you did not love
- +$50 credit for each referred friend who joins
Where it falls short
- −California wines only
- −The site does not list bottles per shipment next to the starting price
- −No taste quiz; the club picks the wineries
- Starting price
- From $49 per shipment
- Clubs
- Premier, Signature and Aged Cabernet Series
- Member discount
- 20% off reorders
- Cancellation
- Anytime, no hidden fees
- Guarantee
- Love It Guarantee
Visit cawineclub.com|Read the full The California Wine Club profile
No. 7
Gold Medal Wine ClubA wine club with three curated levels and gift subscriptions.
7.8of 10Best for Gift buyers who want a simple tiered club
- Performance
- 7.8
- Ease of use
- 8.0
- Value
- 7.6
Price
Gold Wine Club from $49; Platinum from $114; Diamond from $220; shipping extra
Quoted from the Gold Medal Wine Club pricing page on November 12, 2026:
Gold Wine Club Gold Wine Club Regular price From $49.00
Gold Medal Wine Club keeps the choice simple with three club levels, each delivering wines it curates for you: Gold from $49, Platinum from $114 and Diamond from $220. You can buy an ongoing membership, which bills each shipment plus shipping until you cancel, or a gift subscription, and the site also sells one-time gift sets such as Gilded Gold at $49 and Platinum Pair at $114. Members can cancel at any time on their account page, by email or by phone, and the Love It Guarantee replaces a bottle you did not love on your next order. Shipping is extra and varies by destination and bottle count, and the carrier charges a $40 fee to reship if no adult is there to sign. The clubs page lists starting prices but not bottles per shipment, so check the plan details before comparing price per bottle. It is a straightforward choice for gift buyers who want a fixed tier rather than a quiz.
What it does well
- +Cancel anytime on your account page, by email or by phone
- +Love It Guarantee replaces a bottle on your next order
- +Recurring billing only applies to ongoing memberships
Where it falls short
- −Shipping is charged on top of the wine price
- −The clubs page does not list bottles per shipment
- −A $40 reship fee applies if no adult 21+ is home to sign
- Starting price
- From $49 per shipment
- Club levels
- Gold, Platinum and Diamond
- Shipping
- Extra, varies by destination
- Cancellation
- Anytime
- Guarantee
- Love It Guarantee
Visit goldmedalwineclub.com|Read the full Gold Medal Wine Club profile
No. 8
VineboxA monthly tasting box of six sommelier-curated wines in 100 ml glass tubes.
7.2of 10Best for People who want to taste six wines a month without full bottles
- Performance
- 7.0
- Ease of use
- 8.6
- Value
- 6.4
Price
See vendor pricing (USD check pending)
No US price was listed when we checked. See the Vinebox pricing page.
Vinebox is a tasting kit rather than a bottle club. Each month it launches one themed collection on the 1st, with six sommelier-curated wines in 100 ml glass tubes, plus a sommelier-led virtual tasting video, tasting notes and a pairing guide. Each collection is available for that month only. Shipping is a flat $5 for ground delivery, and Vinebox gives 15% off orders of 5 or more Boxes of the Month, which suits group tastings. Subscriptions come in 3, 6 and 12-month options that work as gifts. The trade-off is volume: six 100 ml tubes add up to 600 ml, less than one standard 750 ml bottle, so the cost per glass is far higher than at any bottle club here. Vinebox's subscription page did not load from our location for the price check, so its price is marked pending. Choose it for learning and gifting, not for stocking a wine rack.
What it does well
- +Taste six wines without opening full bottles
- +Flat $5 ground shipping on every order
- +Good for virtual or at-home tasting parties
Where it falls short
- −Six 100 ml tubes total 600 ml, less than a single 750 ml bottle
- −Highest cost per milliliter of wine on this list
- −No personalization; everyone gets the same monthly theme
- Box contents
- 6 wines, 100 ml each
- Frequency
- Monthly
- Shipping
- Flat $5 ground
- Extras
- Tasting videos, notes and pairing guide
- Gift terms
- 3, 6 and 12-month subscriptions
Before you pick a product or a plan
Work out the price per bottle
Clubs quote prices per shipment, per bottle or as an intro box, so convert everything to a price per bottle. Splash Wines' 6 bottles for $59 is about $9.83 a bottle and its 15 bottles for $89 is about $5.93. Wine Access Discovery Club's $150 for 6 bottles is $25 a bottle, and SommSelect's Explore 4 at $118 for 4 bottles is $29.50.
Separate the intro offer from the regular price
Many clubs discount the first box. Firstleaf's Classic plan is $44.95 for the first box, then $99 plus shipping for a regular 6-bottle club order. Splash Wines takes $20 off the first shipment with a code. Budget for the regular price, not the first box.
Check who pays for shipping
Winc and Splash Wines include shipping, and Wine Access includes it for club members. Firstleaf's regular club orders show a price plus shipping, SommSelect adds 1% insurance and shipping, Gold Medal Wine Club charges shipping on top of the wine, and Vinebox charges a flat $5.
Decide how much choice you want
Firstleaf picks wines from a taste quiz and your ratings, Winc lets you take a 6-question quiz or pick every bottle yourself, and Wine Access, SommSelect and The California Wine Club choose for you. If you dislike surprises, pick a club that lets you swap bottles.
Look for a replacement guarantee
Wine Access credits you for any bottle that fails to impress, The California Wine Club and Gold Medal Wine Club replace a bottle you did not love under their Love It Guarantee, and Splash Wines has a Gotta-Love-It Guarantee. Firstleaf offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Buying a gift
Prepaid gift memberships avoid an open-ended subscription. SommSelect sells 3, 6 and 12-month prepaid clubs, Vinebox sells 3, 6 and 12-month subscriptions, and Wine Access, The California Wine Club and Gold Medal Wine Club all offer gift memberships. The recipient must be 21 or older and live in a state the club ships to.
Questions readers ask
- What is the best wine club in 2026?
- Firstleaf is the best wine club for most people in 2026. A taste quiz picks your wines, and the Classic plan costs $44.95 for the first box, then $16.50 per bottle. Wine Access is the best curated club, with 6 bottles a quarter for $150.
- What is the cheapest wine club?
- Splash Wines is the cheapest wine club we found, at 6 bottles for $59 or 15 bottles for $89 with free shipping. The 15-bottle case works out at about $5.93 per bottle, as listed on splashwines.com in November 2026.
- What is the best wine club for a gift?
- Wine Access is the best wine club gift, with its Discovery Club sending 6 bottles a quarter for $150 with shipping included. SommSelect and Vinebox sell prepaid 3, 6 and 12-month options if you want a gift that ends on its own.
- How much does a wine club cost per month?
- Most wine clubs cost about $50 to $150 per shipment. Splash Wines starts at $59 for 6 bottles, The California Wine Club and Gold Medal Wine Club start at $49 a shipment, and Wine Access charges $150 per quarterly box of 6 bottles.
- Can I choose my own wines in a wine club?
- Yes, Winc lets members pick every bottle at 20% off with free shipping. Firstleaf picks for you from a taste quiz and your ratings, while Wine Access, SommSelect and The California Wine Club choose the wines themselves.
- Can I cancel a wine club at any time?
- Yes, all the clubs on this list let you cancel. Wine Access lets you pause or cancel anytime, The California Wine Club says there are no hidden fees, and Winc lets members skip any month.
- Do wine clubs include shipping?
- Some do. Winc, Splash Wines and Wine Access include shipping, while Firstleaf's regular club orders, SommSelect and Gold Medal Wine Club add it at checkout, and Vinebox charges a flat $5.
Spotted an error or a price change? Write to editorial@hearsmart.org
How we work is in our editorial policy. Makers change prices, plans and terms often, so check the price on their site before you buy or upgrade.